We may earn a commission from links on this page. It never affects the Sqwod Score or the ranking.
The picks
#1 NSF-certified basics
Momentous (Creatine + Protein)
85/100 Crowd 86 Assessment 87 Value 76 €45 Subscription: Subscribe & save ~15%
Sports-science supplements with NSF/Informed-Sport testing — safe to recommend to tested athletes.
- Purity / testing9.6
- Efficacy8.8
- Value7
- Taste / mix8.2
- Trust9.4
- Coach fit9
Pros
- NSF Certified for Sport + Informed-Sport — safe for tested athletes
- Creapure creatine; six-stage testing incl. heavy metals, PFAS, microplastics
- Simple, evidence-led formulas (no proprietary-blend games)
Cons
- €1–1.50/serving vs ~€0.20 for commodity creatine
- Cheaper Creapure brands give near-identical results
Buy it if You coach tested athletes (or are cautious) and want certainty over price. Skip it if You're on a tight budget — a Creapure/NSF generic is most of the way there.
#2 Creatine
ESN Ultrapure Creatine Monohydrate
85/100 Crowd 84 Assessment 84 Value 88 €30
Clean, vegan, lab-tested creatine — the most evidence-backed supplement, done right.
- Evidence base9.5
- Purity/testing8.6
- Solubility8.4
- Value9
- Simplicity9
Pros
- The ingredient class with the strongest evidence base of any sports supplement
- Lab-tested and on the Kölner Liste — safe for tested athletes
- Vegan, microfine, tasteless, dissolves well
Cons
- Not branded Creapure — if you specifically want Creapure, pick ESN’s separate SKU
- Official esn.com price runs above the cheapest resellers
Buy it if You (or your clients) want a clean, doping-safe, well-priced creatine — the one foundational supplement worth recommending to almost everyone. Skip it if You specifically require the branded Creapure raw material, or already dose 3–5 g creatine from another source.
#3 All-round whey
Optimum Nutrition Gold Standard 100% Whey
85/100 Crowd 92 Assessment 82 Value 70 €78
The genre-defining whey — great mixability and Informed-Choice tested.
- Quality9
- Mixability9
- Taste8
- Testing/purity9
- Value6
Pros
- Whey isolate as primary source with a strong ~24 g protein per serving
- Renowned easy mixing with almost no clumping
- Informed-Choice / banned-substance tested — safe for tested athletes
Cons
- Premium price per kg versus generic German whey brands
- Some flavours taste quite sweet for certain palates
Buy it if Anyone who wants a proven, lab-tested all-rounder whey with reliable taste and mixing. Skip it if Bargain hunters chasing the lowest price per kg or anyone needing a pure high-percentage isolate.
#4 Value whey
Myprotein Impact Whey Protein
84/100 Crowd 86 Assessment 80 Value 90 €30
The certified ~€30/kg value benchmark — buy it on a discount code.
- Protein/quality8.2
- Testing8.6
- Taste7.5
- Mixability7.4
- Value9.2
Pros
- Very low cost per kg (~€30/kg) with strong protein density (~22–23 g/serving)
- Informed Choice + Informed Protein certified (safe for tested athletes)
- Huge flavour range (50+)
Cons
- Concentrate, not isolate — more lactose/carbs than an isolate
- Taste varies widely by flavour; value hinges on discount codes
Buy it if You (or your clients) want a certified, high-protein daily whey at the lowest reliable cost-per-kg. Skip it if You are lactose-sensitive or chasing the leanest macros — choose the Impact Whey Isolate instead.
#5 German lab-tested whey
ESN Designer Whey Protein
83/100 Crowd 86 Assessment 82 Value 74 €45
Germany's most popular whey — lab-tested quality at a mid-premium price.
- Protein/quality8.6
- Testing8.8
- Taste8.4
- Mixability8.6
- Value7
Pros
- German market leader — the default trusted whey in the DACH region
- Concentrate + isolate complex, up to ~25 g protein per serving
- Rigorously lab-tested (>80k tests/yr, FSSC 22000 / HACCP)
Cons
- Price premium — €44–50/kg sits above discounted rivals like Myprotein
- Polarised taste feedback; limited availability outside the DACH/EU market
Buy it if You are a DACH coach or client who wants a widely-trusted, lab-tested German whey with excellent mixability and broad flavour choice. Skip it if Budget is the deciding factor and you can source a cheaper whey, or the client is outside the EU where ESN is hard to get.
#6 Functional hydration
Waterdrop Microdrink
79/100 Crowd 89 Assessment 76 Value 60 €8
Sugar-light flavor cubes that make drinking more water genuinely easy and sustainable.
- Taste8
- Ingredients7
- Sustainability8
- Convenience9
- Value6
Pros
- Tiny, portable cubes make flavoured water effortless anywhere
- Sugar-free, low-calorie, sweetened with stevia and packed with vitamins (C, B-vitamins, zinc)
- Strong, high-volume customer ratings across Trustpilot and Reviews.io
Cons
- Premium price (~€0.75 per serving) versus plain tap water
- Standard Microdrink is light on electrolytes; you need the Microlyte range for sport
Buy it if Buy it if you struggle to drink enough plain water and want a portable, sugar-free flavour boost with a vitamin top-up. Skip it if Skip it if you need serious electrolyte replenishment for hard training (choose Microlyte instead) or you're price-sensitive.
#7 Protein snack
Barebells Protein Bar
79/100 Crowd 88 Assessment 74 Value 65 €25
The best-tasting mainstream protein bar — 20 g protein, no sugar alcohols, candy-bar texture.
- Taste/texture9
- Protein/macros8
- Ingredients5
- Availability9
- Value6
Pros
- Excellent candy-bar taste and texture across most flavours
- 20g protein and only ~1.5g sugar per bar (0g added sugar)
- Available almost everywhere in Germany: REWE, dm, Rossmann, Edeka, Amazon.de
Cons
- Sweetened with maltitol (sugar alcohol) plus sucralose - can cause bloating/digestive upset in quantity
- Carbs are not as low as the sugar figure suggests (sugar alcohols)
Buy it if Buy it if you want a high-protein, low-sugar snack that actually tastes like a treat and you can find it in nearly every supermarket. Skip it if Skip it if you're sensitive to sugar alcohols like maltitol or want a minimal, clean-label ingredient list.
#8 Daily multivitamin
Ritual Essential for Women 18+
78/100 Crowd 82 Assessment 80 Value 62 US$33/mo Subscription: $33/mo
Transparent, USP-verified vegan multivitamin — a clean fill-the-gaps default.
- Quality8.5
- Transparency9
- Testing9
- Completeness6.5
- Value7
Pros
- USP Verified plus Clean Label Project tested — genuine third-party assurance
- Full ingredient traceability (Made Traceable supplier disclosure)
- Vegan, non-GMO, gluten-free with methylated B12/folate and delayed-release capsule
Cons
- Minimalist 9-nutrient formula — no vitamin C, calcium, or most B vitamins
- Subscription-first at ~$33/mo — pricier than many multivitamins
Buy it if You have a generally balanced diet and want a clean, third-party-verified vegan 'fill-the-gaps' supplement. Skip it if You want a comprehensive all-in-one multi, a budget option, or you're in Germany/EU without a forwarding service.
#9 Complete-meal drink
yfood Vital Drink
77/100 Crowd 80 Assessment 78 Value 62 €4
Germany's category leader: 500 kcal, 33 g protein and 26 vitamins with genuinely good taste.
- Nutrition profile8
- Taste9
- Convenience10
- Ingredients6
- Value6
Pros
- Complete macro/micro profile: ~33g protein, 26 vitamins & minerals per 500ml
- Consistently praised taste across flavors (Cold Brew Coffee, Vanilla, Choco)
- Ultra-convenient, shelf-stable, no prep — ideal on the go
Cons
- Expensive: ~€3–4 per bottle, price 'rather high' vs competitors
- Processed base — maltodextrin and sunflower/rapeseed oil blend
Buy it if Buy it if you regularly skip meals and need a fast, balanced, genuinely tasty option that beats a fast-food grab. Skip it if Skip it if you want to replace most meals long-term, watch every euro, or prefer minimally processed whole-food nutrition.
#10 Gut health
Seed DS-01 Daily Synbiotic
76/100 Crowd 80 Assessment 78 Value 58 US$50/mo Subscription: $49.99/mo
Broad 24-strain synbiotic with an acid-protective capsule and real (if brand-funded) trials.
- Formula8.5
- Delivery (ViaCap)8.5
- Testing8.5
- Evidence7
- Value6
Pros
- Broad 24-strain formula (53.64B AFU) with an acid-protective ViaCap capsule
- Shelf-stable, vegan, third-party tested (heavy metals, allergens, glyphosate)
- Company has published actual RCTs on the full formulation — rare in the category
Cons
- Subscription-first, ~$49.99/mo — expensive vs shelf competitors
- No direct EU/Germany shipping — freight forwarder + 19% VAT raises true cost
Buy it if You want a science-forward, broad-spectrum daily synbiotic and are fine with a recurring ~$50/month subscription. Skip it if You're in Germany/EU wanting easy local delivery, a budget option, or independent (non-brand-funded) proof first.
#11 Race-day fuel
Maurten GEL 100
75/100 Crowd 95 Assessment 66 Value 40 €37
Superbly gut-friendly endurance gel elites swear by (at a premium).
- Efficacy8
- Digestibility9
- Taste/texture6
- Evidence6
- Value4
Pros
- Exceptionally gentle on the stomach, even at high carb intake during long efforts
- Clean, minimalist formula (carbs, water, no colours or preservatives) trusted by elite marathoners
- Reliable 25 g carbs per 40 g gel with a neutral, easy-to-swallow taste
Cons
- Premium price of roughly €3 per gel — among the most expensive on the market
- The hydrogel "reduces GI distress" claim is scientifically debated and not clearly proven vs standard gels
Buy it if Serious marathoners, triathletes and ultra runners with a sensitive stomach who want maximum reliability on race day and don't mind paying for it. Skip it if Budget-conscious athletes or anyone whose gut already tolerates cheaper standard gels just fine — you're mostly paying for the brand and format.
#12 Convenience greens
AG1 (Athletic Greens)
66/100 Crowd 68 Assessment 72 Value 45 €87/mo Subscription: €87/mo subscription (30 servings, ~€2.90/serving)
Exhaustively tested greens powder — convenient, but premium-priced with thin evidence.
- Third-party testing9
- Ingredients7
- Transparency5
- Evidence5
- Value3.5
Pros
- Broad all-in-one micronutrient, probiotic and adaptogen profile
- Genuinely rigorous testing — NSF Certified for Sport (meaningful for tested athletes)
- Vegan, gluten/dairy-free, no added sugar; 90-day money-back guarantee
Cons
- High cost — ~€87/month, far above €1.50–2/serving competitors
- Proprietary blend: ingredients listed but per-dose amounts hidden
Buy it if You are busy, won’t reliably eat varied produce, want a banned-substance-tested all-in-one, and the price is not a barrier. Skip it if You are on a budget or already eat a balanced diet — a good diet plus a cheap NSF multivitamin covers most of the same ground.
Frequently asked questions
Which supplements actually have strong evidence behind them?
A short list, and it is much shorter than the shelf suggests. Creatine monohydrate, caffeine and protein for meeting intake targets are the ones with repeated meta-analytic support for training outcomes. Most of the rest sits somewhere between promising and unproven — our Sqwod Evidence briefings grade each claim and link the studies rather than asking you to take our word for it.
What does third-party tested actually mean?
That an independent lab verified the product contains what the label claims and no undisclosed contaminants. It matters because supplements are not pre-approved the way medicines are, so without it you are trusting the manufacturers own word. For anyone subject to competition testing it is not optional.
How do I compare supplement prices properly?
Per effective dose, not per container. Work out the cost of one serving at the dose the research used — per five grams for creatine, per gram of protein for powder, per elemental milligram for minerals. Tub size and scoop size are the two variables most often used to make a product look cheaper than it is.
Do I need to cycle creatine?
No. The evidence supports a consistent daily dose without cycling, and loading phases are optional — they fill stores faster but reach the same place. Consistency matters far more than timing or protocol.
Does an affiliate link affect how you score supplements?
No. Commission never affects the Sqwod Score or the ranking — scores follow the published methodology only, affiliate links are labelled and marked rel="sponsored", and we publish low scores. There are products on this site scoring in the sixties that we still earn commission on.
